Who’ll Freeze First? A Puzzle About Size and Staying Warm

  • Forty two years ago, I read an essay from 1928 by J. B. S. Haldane titled "On Being the Right Size" [1], it appeared in the wonderful four volume set The World of Mathematics.

    I've always remembered the main point: volume and properties related to volume increase as the cube of the scale factor for similar objects while area (surface or cross-section) increase as the square. See for example the Google interview question that appears in the movie "The Internship".

    [1] http://irl.cs.ucla.edu/papers/right-size.html

  • I thought it was always a "common knowledge" that small animals tend to eat constantly and suffer sooner from food shortage because of higher relative heat dissipation. Some mice eat up to 50-80% of their weight per day, opposed to just few percents for biggies like elephants. Mice also have much faster metabolism in the same conditions.

  • The same concept applies to animal (and plant, building, structure, etc.) size: weight varies with the cube of the "size", while the cross-section of the supporting structures (trunk, legs, etc.) varies with the square.

    So the relationship "weight/supported weight" increases with size, to the point where it won't support itself.

  •     In Professor Haskell’s book, The Forest Unseen, he says he wanted to “experience the cold as the forest’s animals do, without the protection of clothes,”
    
    When was next Darwin awards?