Ask HN: Is a PhD worth its time?

  • Is there something you want to spend all your time thinking about, working more than full-time thinking about, while also having a job that seems to give you no responsibility other then thinking about things (and maybe teaching), while also giving you a smaller salary than you are likely used to? Then yes, a PhD is likely a good life experience for you.

    I have a PhD and I think it was a good use of my time. I got to study things I am interested in, I developed skills and thoughts on interesting topics, while also having a coffee break or going to do something else whenever I felt like it. Getting a PhD also got me the job I always wanted (research scientist in a corporate lab). I would not have this job without a PhD.

    There seems to be a lot of hiring in industry right now at the overlap between domain expertise and machine learning/computational science (this has probably been true since computers became fashionable). So if you don't really care about being a software developer you could probably get a job after a PhD having been a software developer at some domain intersection where you might be programming a lot that would likely justify the PhD you received.

    I mean the truth is, nobody here can tell you what to do, it's your life, do whatever you want. Some people enjoy doing a PhD, other people hate it. In my experience, people without a phd typically believe they know what getting a phd is like, people with phd's have all silently and collectively agreed to not discuss the traumatic parts.

  • From what I understand, a PHD is absolutely not worth it for the vast majority of people. There may be a few exceptions for a small number of hyper specialized occupations that require a PHD.

    Most of the people I know who got a PHD did it for immigration reasons.

  • Everything you've said points to "no."