Are top stories biased towards the preferences of those who browse the new page?

  • No, I browse the new page because the top stories are mostly irrelevant to me.

  • If the worth of new posts was not judged by users who view new posts, how else should they be judged?

  • I was browsing an old thread about this, and this comment from 2010 put it very well https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1076422 which is where I got the phrasing of the title from