Ask HN: What lo-tech do you use for kids to play music?

  • Dedicated mp3 players might work well for this. I (no kids) have been using a Sansa Clip with Rockbox for 10 years. It checks all the boxes you mentioned. I fear for the day it dies.

    I've heard that newer Sansas aren't compatible with Rockbox, and the ones that are sell for ~$50 secondhand.

  • To make control easier, a locked down tablet? E.g. a Kindle Fire Kids is inexpensive (but hardware is on the lean side and you have to work hard to avoid the Amazon ecosystem trap).

  • nsuring a lo-tech and screen-free environment for your kids while still allowing them to enjoy music is a thoughtful approach. Here are some professional suggestions:

    Kid-Friendly Music Players: Consider dedicated music players designed for children. These devices often come with pre-loaded songs, eliminating the need for screens. Some models even allow you to add your own music.

    MP3 Players: Opt for simple MP3 players with controls that are easy for children to use. Load them with a curated selection of songs, allowing your kids to have a music library without the distractions of screens.

    CD Players: Introduce your kids to the joy of using CD players. You can create custom playlists on CDs, making it a tangible and interactive experience for them.

    Parental Controls on Devices: If you choose to use a laptop or tablet, implement strict parental controls. This allows you to limit access to specific apps or websites, ensuring a controlled and safe environment.

    Music Subscription Services: Some music subscription services offer family plans that allow you to create kid-friendly profiles with curated content. Explore these options to tailor the music experience for your children.

    Smart Speakers: Consider a smart speaker with voice controls. You can program it to play specific songs or playlists without the need for a screen.

    Musical Instruments: Encourage your children to explore making music themselves. Simple instruments like xylophones or recorders can provide a hands-on and creative musical experience.

    Radio: Introduce them to traditional radio. Tune in to child-friendly stations or programs that offer a mix of music suitable for their age.

    By incorporating these alternatives, you can create a positive musical environment for your kids without relying on screens. Adjusting the options based on their age and preferences will ensure an engaging and developmentally appropriate experience.