I disagree with the implication that flat structures "don't scale" or can never work. To be effective in a flat environment requires a fundamental shift in perspective. Hierarchy is so baked in to every other company, organization, and education system that people just don't know how to operate absent it.
ICs will need time to adjust to a flat structure, and some people will do anything to fight the absence of the restrictions they've always known. Hiring a bunch of senior ICs from traditional industry roles and saying "we're not going to have managers!" is always going to fail.
For a CTO/founder it's even easier: If you're building a VC-funded start-up where the plan is to grow fast exit in a few years — what's the point? Why invest the effort and energy to making flat work when the moment you get bought out the hierarchy is back anyway.
There are examples of stable large companies with flat org charts that do work, they're just not the hypergrowth scale-ups. The book "Reinventing Organizations" covers several in depth, and is a good intro to the topic. So my objection is the implication that a flat structure can never work, or that there is something fundamental about a flat org and human nature that means it's unstable. It is simply that it requires long-term investment to get right, and the market isn't setup to reward long-term investment.
There is no flat organisation in business. Such a communist thing cannot exist in the context of capitalism. The lack of hierarchy can only mean one of three things: making decisions as a committee and bleeding time, money and ideas; having social hierarchies dominate and letting narcissism and sociopathy run wild, or descending into anarchy where profitable decisionmakers are gilded and unprofitable ones are pruned.
All the creatives are worried that Gen AI will steal their jobs. Seems to me that the most likely candidate for replacement is the manager. Their primary job is summary and communication, an ideal fit for an LLM. If you already coordinate your company around Google docs, the AI has access to all the information about company's status, even all the emails.