Proposal: Add "No Screen Sharing" Flag for Secure Messaging Apps

  • I strongly object to this idea that this is not under user control. Far too many companies and governments seek to control what their users do with data and information and devices that are supposed to be in the control of the user. If you don't trust someone to handle secure information securely perhaps you shouldn't be sending them secure information.

    If you're saying you want this to be an optional thing, perhaps even defaulted to enabled to protect grandma from doing something, then I would support that. But it needs to be optional. This mindset of a company can dictate every potential use case to end users is foolishness and doesn't slow down hackers but just irritates normal users who need those features. Just like right now apps can flag whether you can do screenshots or not. In normal situations banking apps other secure messaging apps one time view of photo apps this is all quite useful but it shouldn't be an enforced requirement that you have to then hack your phone to override it. It should be a default that's enabled that you can then disable. Now if you want the sending party to know if you've disabled that feature that's fine as well it's simply more information. Then the sender can decide what they want to do. The idea of completely removing control as if you know better needs to stop.

    Things will not get better with technology or literally anything if we cannot require people to be responsible for their actions. Sensible defaults are great a sensible default to have this on is fine a system that notifies other parties during a communication if it's on or off is fine. Removal of control from the user is wrong.

  • I don't think it is appropriate (and feasible) to let app an developer decide how exactly and when _I_ share _MY_ screen on _MY_ phone.